C4GG Logo

Search

Search across all content

Submission Guidelines

Follow these guidelines to ensure your contributions meet our standards for accuracy and quality.

General Principles

  • Use neutral, factual language. Avoid emotionally charged words or editorializing.
  • Every claim must be backed by evidence — source links, documents, or media.
  • No personal attacks, insults, or harassment directed at officials or other users.
  • Focus on actions and decisions, not personal opinions about an official's character.
  • When in doubt, provide more evidence and context, not less.

Adding Officials

  • Full name is required (2–200 characters). Use the official's legal or commonly known name.
  • Aliases and biographical information are optional but helpful for identification.
  • Jurisdiction level must be specified: national, regional, or local.
  • Terms of service should include position title, start/end dates, and mode of entry (elected, appointed, inherited, etc.).
  • The system will check for similar existing official profiles to prevent duplicates.

Submitting Deeds

  • Title (10–500 characters): A clear, factual summary of the action.
  • Description (50–10,000 characters): Detailed account of what happened, including context, dates, and involved parties.
  • Category is required. Choose the most relevant from: Infrastructure, Lawmaking, Administrative, Budget, Procurement, Public Health, Education, Environment, Social Services, Law Enforcement, Disaster Response, Appointments, Public Statements, Inaction, or Other.
  • Secondary tags (optional): Add tags like Transparency, Accountability, Efficiency, Equity, Corruption Risk, Human Rights, Public Safety, Emergency Powers, or Private Sector Involvement.
  • Claimed impact (optional): Indicate whether the action had a positive, negative, mixed, or neutral impact.
  • Source URLs should link to official documents, news articles, or government records.
  • Evidence files should support the deed's claims directly.

Evidence Standards

Accepted File Formats

Images: JPEG, PNG, GIF, WebP
Documents: PDF
Videos: MP4, WebM

Maximum file size: 10 MB per file.

  • Evidence must be directly relevant to the deed it supports.
  • Do not upload doctored, manipulated, or misleading media.
  • Screenshots should include visible dates and sources where possible.

Source Requirements

  • Link to official government documents, press releases, or public records when available.
  • News articles from established media outlets are acceptable sources.
  • Multiple independent sources are preferred for stronger verification.
  • Social media posts from official government accounts can be used as supporting sources.
  • Avoid linking to opinion pieces, editorials, or blog posts as primary sources.

What Gets Rejected

  • Duplicate content — Check if the deed already exists before submitting.
  • Unverifiable claims — Submissions without evidence or credible sources.
  • Personal opinions disguised as factual deeds.
  • Harassment or personal attacks against officials or users.
  • Spam or promotional content unrelated to governance.
  • Misleading or out-of-context information presented as fact.

Moderation Process

  • All deed submissions are reviewed by moderators before being published.
  • Dynasty suggestions for officials are reviewed separately.
  • Delete requests go through moderator approval — content is hidden pending review rather than immediately removed.
  • Moderators can hide, archive, delete, or restore content. Admins can permanently delete already-deleted content.
  • Deleted comments display a [deleted] placeholder to preserve thread structure.

Reputation Impact

Deed approved & published+10 points
Deed rejected-5 points
Receive agree vote+2 points
Receive disagree vote-1 point
Vote on a deed+1 point
Post a comment+1 point

Daily limits apply: 20 vote participations, 10 trust votes, and 10 comments per day.